Instructions:
Hi Everyone--
I compiled a table of your evidence/rules/conclusions. I also included 10 incomplete entries. After carefully reading through the entire page, look at the incomplete entries that I have assigned and post in the comments section how you would complete them. I will add them to the table after you have submitted them.
Please do this by Saturday evening, as I would like to then post the next part of the assignment for you to complete before Tuesday.
Summary of our evidence, ‘rules’ and conclusions regarding Queenie and Arthur.
Our question: Is
Queenie lying?
“Evidence” can include:
·
Concrete, observable information (such as what
we see happening in the picture of the crime scene)
·
Personal testimony (Queenie’s statement)
·
Written documents (in this case, autopsy
results)
·
Material objects and their condition or
appearance (none here, although we can look at the objects in the drawing and
speculate about them
Rules or Warrants:
How do we explain our evidence?
What generally accepted principles might apply to the evidence we have
chosen?
Conclusion:
What can we conclude, based on our Evidence and Rules? Remember, we can take the same evidence and
come to different conclusions, depending on the “rule” we apply to it. For example, yesterday the glass in Arthur’s
hand was interpreted differently based on other evidence and the rules that
were applied to that evidence.
Queenie’s Statement: “Slip or Trip?”
At five-feet-six and a hundred and ten
pounds, Queenie Volupides was a sight to behold. When she tore out of the house after a tiff
with her husband, Arthur, she went to the country club where there was a party
going on.
She left the club shortly before one in the
morning and invited a few friends to follow her home and have one more
drink. They got to the Volupides house
about ten minutes after Queenie, who met them at the door and said, “Something
terrible happened. Arthur slipped and
fell on the stairs. He was coming down
for another drink—he still had the glass in his hand—and I think he’s
dead. Oh, my God—what shall I do?
The autopsy conducted later concluded that
Arthur had died from a wound on the head and confirmed that he had been drunk.
Evidence
|
Rule (Warrant)
|
Conclusion (Claim)
|
Queenie does not seem particularly upset. (1)
|
In these types of situations people usually appear emotional and
possibly hysterical.
|
Queenie is lying
|
Queenie does not seem particularly upset. (2)
|
People deal with these types of situations differently. Some go into shock.
|
Queenie is telling the truth (she’s just in shock).
|
Arthur’s feet are on the bottom step
|
In general, when people are unconscious, their bodies go limp, and
gravity will pull their bodies down to the ground.
|
Queenie is lying
|
Arthur’s clothes are perfectly smoothed and neat.
|
When people fall, their clothes usually become disheveled
|
Queenie is lying
|
Queenie says Arthur “slipped on
the stairs.”
|
This phrase “slipped on the
stairs” is often used to describe slipping
off a step, not necessarily falling down a flight of stairs.
|
Queenie [may be] telling the truth.
|
Arthur is lying face up (1)
|
As a rule, when people fall down the stairs, they land face forward
|
Queenie is lying
|
Arthur is lying face up (2) and Queenie says Arthur “slipped on the
stairs.”
|
When people slip on a lower step facing up the stairs, they generally
fall backwards.
|
Tentative conclusion that would need more evidence: Queenie may
be telling the truth. However, she
says that Arthur was coming down for a drink. Maybe that was her assumption;
we don’t know if she saw Arthur
fall.
|
Food on the stove is hot/cooking
|
It takes more than 10 minutes to prepare food and then get it to
temperature.
|
Queenie could not have been the one to start
the food.
Arthur must have been cooking.
He could not have been dead long, or the food
would have been burning.
|
The tie on Arthur’s belt is not centered, as expected (Avery)
|
||
Arthur is lying with his head on the rug. (Arva)
|
||
There is a glass in Arthur’s hand. (Daniel)
|
||
The position of the glass in Arthur’s hand is not a natural position.(Camille)
|
||
The pan on the stove shows the handle being to the right. The glass is in Arthur’s left hand. (Iman)
|
||
The mirror and other objects hanging on the wall along the stairs are
undisturbed. (Iman)
|
||
The carpet is undisturbed (Camille)
|
||
Queenie and Arthur had been fighting prior to her storming out. (Daniel)
|
||
Arthur had been drunk. (Avery)
|
||
Queenie invited friends to come to her house (Arva)
|
Additional things you thought about
We don’t know whether she witnessed this happening, or was
basing her story on conjecture.
If this is in the 1950s, it is unlikely Arthur would have
been cooking, because men did not typically cook in the 1950s.
The glass may be plastic
1) It could have moved when he fell! Queenie could be telling the truth.
ReplyDelete2) it makes no difference. Queenie may be telling the truth.
3) when you fall you usualy drop what you are holding. Queenie may be lying.
4) So someone might have placed it there. Queenie maybe lying.
5) Aurther may be a lefty.
6) Aurther might have fallen and hit the banister not the wall. Queenie may be telling the truth.
7) When people fall on a rug it will often crumple up. Queenie may be lying.
8) When Americans get mad at each other they tend to get fisacal. Queenie may be lying
9) Drunk people tend to stumble around and sometimes fall down more then usual.Queenie may be telling the truth
10) When people break the law they tend to make up a story to blame on someone or something else. Queenie may be lying.
Those are lots of great ideas, Camille. You would need to support them with "evidence." For the assignment, you just need to supply the "Rule" and the "Conclusion" for the two pieces of evidence with your name after them.
DeleteWrite your responses in the comment section here, and I will then add everyone's to the table.
The tie on the jacket is not centered.
ReplyDeleteRule: Smoking jackets are made with centered ties. It would be very hard for the tie to slip through the belt loops with the weight of a grown man on it.
Conclusion: Queenie is lying.
Arthur was drunk.
Rule:
When someone is drunk, their reactions are slowed, their coordination poor, and their balance off. Arthur could have easily fallen down the stairs.
Conclusion: Queenie is telling the truth.
*NOTE: This does not explain why everything around Arthur is neat and perfect.
Nice job, Avery.
DeleteThe mirror and other objects hanging on the wall along the stairs are undisturbed
ReplyDeleteRule: When someone is drunk, and they fall down the stairs, its not likely that they fell straight down.
Conclusion: If Arthur really fell on the stairs like Queenie mentioned, its almost impossible that he fell without disturbing all the things on the wall.
Queenie may be lying.
Close, Iman--part of your conclusion actually belongs with the rule.
DeleteRule: When someone falls down stairs, they usually will knock things off the wall while they are trying to catch themselves.
Conclusion: Arthur didn't fall down the stairs--Queenie is lying.
Does that make sense?
If we were to write it out as a series of logical steps, it would be something like this:
The items hanging on the wall by the stairs are undisturbed.
When people fall down stairs they usually knock things off the wall.
Therefore Arthur did not fall down the stairs.
The pan on the stove shows the handle being to the right. The glass is in Arthur’s left hand.
ReplyDeleteRule: When people cook, they have the handle of the pan opposite from their dominant hand. The pan handle was facing the right, which means that Arthurs dominant hand is his left.
The glass in Arthurs hand is on his left. Usually people drink with their right (if they are right-handed)
Conclusion: Arthur cooked what is on the stove. The glass may not have been placed in his hand. Queenie may be telling the truth.
This one is harder--two pieces of evidence. It is also a very tricky one! I think you actually provided more info than necessary:
DeleteRule: When people cook, they turn and hold the pan on the side of their non-dominant hand.
As a rule, people drink by holding a glass in their dominant hand.
Conclusion: Arthur cooked what is on the stove.
We can also speculate, as you said, that the glass was not placed in his hand, as suspected, and that Queenie may be telling the truth, but we would need more support than we have in order to prove this.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete1. Arthur is laying with his head on the rug.
ReplyDeleteRule: Usually, when people slip and fall on the stairs when going up, they fall backwards with their head on the rug, facing upwards.
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
2. Queenie invited friends to come to her house.
Rule: When people want company or in this case, another drink, they invite others over.
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
For #1, your Rule needs to relate to the Evidence. Hint: Our observation about his head being on the rug has to do with his head wound.
DeleteFor #2, your rule doesn't explain the evidence. This IS a hard one. Hint: Think about whether someone who killed their husband would invite people over to her house--why/why not?
This comment has been removed by the author.
Delete1. Arthur is laying with his head on the rug.
DeleteRule: When going up the stairs, a person can hit their head while slipping and then fall backwards which would cause their head to be on the rug, as well as have a head wound. (Arthur could have easily hit his head on the banister while slipping.)
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
2. Queenie invited friends to come to her house.
Rule: Usually, killers try not to bring attention to the fact that they've killed someone. If Queenie had killed her husband, she would not have invite friends over to her house.
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
For #2:
DeleteAnother conclusion could be that Queenie is lying.
Rule: Sometimes, killers act like everything is normal so they are not suspected of murder. Queenie could have invited her friends over so they wouldn't suspect that she killed her husband.
#2 is better!
Delete#1 is pretty similar to your first attempt.
As it is written right now, your 'rule' says:
1. When going up the stairs, a person can hit their head while slipping.
(This is confusing--the wording is unclear. Not sure what you're describing)
2. They can then fall backwards, causing their head to be on the rug
(Do you mean they hit their head in part 1, and then fall backwards down the stairs? Also, not all stairs have rugs at the bottom, so we cannot include that as a 'general rule.')
3. This can also give them a head wound (What can give them a head wound? How?)
4. Arthur could have hit is head on the banister while slipping (possibly, but you would then need to identify the evidence that supports this. This is actually a conclusion, not a rule).
Try to make it more simple; it seem that perhaps you're thinking too hard. Hint: If someone falls with their head on a rug, are they likely to suffer a fatal wound?
Hmm. I see what you're saying. I'm trying out different things right now... How's this?
Delete1. Arthur is laying with his head on the rug.
Rule: When going up the stairs, if a person slips and falls backwards, their head could be hit hard somewhere which could cause them to have a head wound.
Arthur could have been going up the stairs, slipped, hit his head anywhere really hard and then end up on the rug at the bottom of stairs.
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
I'm thinking that she could have hit him or something else could have happened but I would need evidence for that..
The position of the glass in Aurthers hand is not a natural position.
ReplyDeleteRule: Usually, when a person falls they will drop whatever they are holding so they can break their fall.
Conclusion: Queenie is lying.
The carpet is undisturbed.
Rule: Depending upon the weight and/or size of the carpet it is posible for it to be undisterbed.
Conclusion: Queenie may be telling the truth.
Nice job, Camille!
ReplyDeleteInterestingly, your second piece of evidence could have been used either way--to demonstrate that Queenie is telling the truth, or that Queenie is lying.
To show that she was lying, we would use the rule that "if a person slams down the stairs onto the carpet, the carpet would be disturbed." Conclusion: Queenie is lying.